F1
Massa: ‘Briatore lied to me – and Todt was sure crash was deliberate’
Felipe Massa has said both Flavio Briatore and Nelson Piquet Jr denied trying to influence the 2008 Singapore GP when he questioned them
Ecclestone and Mosley both knew about Crashgate in 2008, the former said in a 2023 interview
Getty Images
Bernie Ecclestone and Max Mosley were joined in “a deliberate concealment of a conspiracy” by not investigating the 2008 Crashgate scandal immediately, Felipe Massa’s lawyer claimed in court today.
The former Ferrari driver is seeking to be recognised as the ‘rightful’ champion of the 2008 F1 season and is also claiming £64m in damages from Formula One Management, its then-head Bernie Ecclestone and the FIA.
Massa has argued at a pre-trial hearing at London’s Royal Courts of Justice that the results of the Singapore 2008 ‘Crashgate’ race, in which Nelson Piquet Jr drove into the wall deliberately to help his Renault team manipulate the grand prix, should have been annulled, therefore giving him the title instead of Lewis Hamilton.
His case rests on a 2023 interview in which Ecclestone said he and then FIA president Max Mosley had the information they needed to act on Crashgate, and therefore annul the race, in its immediate aftermath, but didn’t so as to not draw the sport into a scandal.
Ecclestone with Renault boss Flavio Briatore at the 2009 British GP
Grand Prix Photo
Massa’s lawyer, Nick De Marco KC, argued his client had not run out of time to bring a claim, as is asserted by the defendants, because it was only Mr Ecclestone’s interview in 2023 that revealed the truth.
“After many years that interview is the first time it became apparent to Mr Massa that there had been a deliberate concealment of a conspiracy that was known,” De Marco said.
“The defendants are very eager to prevent the court from examining their serious wrongdoing.”
Felipe Massa has said both Flavio Briatore and Nelson Piquet Jr denied trying to influence the 2008 Singapore GP when he questioned them
The barrister continued to say the defendants were trying to mischaracterise his client’s case in order to argue he is out of time and of trying to reopen the results of the race. He argued that for the FIA now to say it has no responsibility to deliver sporting fairness is contradictory.
“The FIA owed a duty and to other members to enforce its regulations,” De Marco said.
“The FIA recognised that duty when they belatedly investigated the crash in 2009.” De Marco added it had failed in its duties in 2008 when Nelson Piquet’s father first approached the governing body saying the shunt may have been deliberate.
“Mr Ecclestone’s interview confirms this when he said the FIA had sufficient evidence to investigate the crash and should have done so then,” De Marco continued.
“The international sporting governing body whose whole purpose and reason it has powers is to protect the integrity of the sport.”
De Marco alleged that the September 2009 World Motor Sport Council report into Crashgate, signed by the then-FIA President, the late Max Mosley, was worded deliberately so as not to implicate those in charge of F1 (i.e. Mosley and Ecclestone) for not acting as soon as they were told of the scandal.
“After the race, the sequence of events described above, giving rise to such an obvious benefit for Renault F1 and Mr Alonso, had raised suspicion and there was a degree of speculation that Mr Piquet Jnr’s crash had been deliberate,” the report read.
Massa’s lawyer says the Crashgate report was deliberately worded so as not to implicate Mosley or Ecclestone in a conspiracy
Getty Images
“Rumours continued to circulate in the weeks that followed the race.
“Mr Piquet Jr’s father, Nelson Piquet Sr, indicated privately to an FIA official that the crash may have been deliberate, though at that time Mr Piquet Jnr was still under contract with Renault F1 and it was understood that he would not be prepared to make a statement to the FIA.
“The FIA considered its position and concluded that it did not have sufficient evidence at that time to launch a detailed investigation.”
Felipe Massa says his Ferrari team was extremely unhappy with comments he made about Fernando Alonso’s role in ‘Crashgate’
De Marco built to a crescendo as he argued that the Ecclestone interview contradicted the ‘insufficient evidence’ argument, as well as the report saying the crash “may have been deliberate.”
“That was a lie, that’s the opposite to the truth!” he thundered. “The people who wrote this report, Ecclestone and Mosley, knew they had sufficient evidence but were worried about the consequences so covered it up.”
De Marco repeatedly highlighted that it was only the 2023 interview that gave Massa the legitimacy of a claim.
In the interview Ecclestone had added “he felt sorry for Mr Massa and he was cheated out of the title.”
“Pausing there, he was cheated by Ecclestone and Mosley,” said De Marco.
“There was nothing to put him on alert that Mr Ecclestone and Mr Mosley had all the information they needed to act, when they said quite the opposite.
“That 2023 interview was the first time, as you will see, that there was evidence of a deliberate concealment.”
The hearing as to whether to strikeout the Massa vs F1 and other continues.
The FIA’s legal defence has slammed Felipe Massa’s 2008 title conspiracy claim as the ‘Crashgate’ hearing kicked off in London
Felipe Massa has said both Flavio Briatore and Nelson Piquet Jr denied trying to influence the 2008 Singapore GP when he questioned them
Felipe Massa faces a multi-million pound bill if he loses his High Court case to be recognised as 2008 F1 champion. By pressing on, the former Ferrari driver is showing that winning still means everything
Felipe Massa is due in court this week, claiming that Bernie Ecclestone and other F1 officials covered up Crashgate, and that he is the rightful 2008 world champion in place of Lewis Hamilton. Here’s the full story so far of his £64m compensation case
One of F1’s biggest-ever scandals, this is the full story of ‘Crashgate’ — what happened, plus why and how it affected the outcome of the 2008 world championship between Felipe Massa and Lewis Hamilton
Star sports lawyer Nick De Marco has been involved in some of the most significant football cases ever seen, and now he’s fronting Felipe Massa’s attempt to take on F1